Monday, 16 May 2016

Brusilov's offensive - June-September 1916

Aleksei Alekseevich Brusilov
1853-1926
Apart from the initial successes at Lemberg (Lviv) and in Galicia in 1914; plus some limited success at the Lake Narotch in early 1916 (see Eastern Front Action 25/1/16) the Russians had endured a miserable two years. Following defeats at Tannenberg; throughout Poland, and most dramatically at Gorlice-Tarnow they had endured a long retreat to a 500 miles front running north to south from the Baltic to the Eastern Carpathian mountains. After a relatively quiet winter, however, they had regained momentum in terms of men, communications and armaments production; and since the Chantilly conference in late 1915, were co-ordinating their efforts better with the Western Front allies. 
So who was Brusilov? The only General throughout the whole of WW1 to have his name attached to a strategic campaign - a distinction that eluded Joffre, Foch, Haig etc. -  he must have been an impressive man.
General Aleksei Brusilov was aged 60 at the outbreak of war in 1914, and by mid 1916 was one of the few people to have been involved in action continuously since that time. Like many senior generals his training had been as a Cavalry officer, but he recognised the central role of infantry tactics in modern warfare. He distinguished himself in the early advances following Lemberg, and again in early 1915 when he led the further advances as far as the Hungarian plain. It was the disaster at Gorlice-Tarnow that forced his reversal, and thereafter he had to lead rearguard actions during the long Russian withdrawals from Galicia and Poland. Favoured by the Tsar after his successes, he gained promotions and decorations and in April 1916 was given control of the southernmost sector of the front. The tactics he introduced for his offensive led to Russia's greatest successes of the war, and were adopted by other combatants as the war ground onwards - notably the German shock troops of late 1917 and 1918. Brusilov is viewed as one of the great fighting commanders of WW1. Following the February Revolution in 1917, he was made Commander in Chief of the Russian army but was relieved of his post before the Bolshevik Revolution in November, during which he was badly injured. He died in 1924, aged 70, and received a state funeral from the Bolsheviks.

Brusilov's starting point (left) and the double bulge north
and south (right) created by the advances of Khaledin
and Lechitski
The Russians were planning to move in concert with their Allies in Summer 1916, at a moment when the Germans were maximally committed at Verdun and the Somme offensive had started. The Russian Commander-in-Chief (nominally the Tsar) had his 500 mile front covered by three army groups: the NorthWest, led by Kuropatkin; the West, led by Ewart; and the Southwest group led by Ivanov. Ewart's central group was best placed to make a significant push towards Germany, but all three commanders, scarred by their experiences to date, were defensively minded and reluctant to take the initiative against the Germans. However, in April, Ivanov was recalled to Imperial HQ, and Brusilov was promoted to take over leadership of the SW Army group. Resolved to act at once, Brusilov gained permission to attack along the entirety of his sector - nearly three hundred miles from the Pripet Marshes in the north to Cernowitz and the River Dniester in the south. Because of the pressure in Italy from Trentino, this was before the start of the Somme campaign. Breaking with perceived wisdom, his artillery preparation was intense but very short, and he allocated all of his reserves to the initial assault. Brusilov had four armies within his group, all led by experienced generals, and they attacked in five sectors right along his front. Following the bombardment of 12-20 hours, the attacks began on June 5th. The northernmost group could make little headway through the flooded terrain of the Pripet Marshes, but to the south Generals Kaledin and Sakharov made a major breakthrough in the Volhynian triangle, comprising the fortress towns of Rovno, Dubno and Lutsk. The Austrians made a headlong and hasty retreat.
Similar dramatic success was achieved in the far south where Lechitski's 9th army advanced rapidly along the Dniester into the Bukovina region of Galicia. However, in the centre the Austrian and German resistance, led by Bothner, was stiffer and progress was slower. This meant that the two leading groups of Brusilov were diverging, and this would prove to be a problem later when German reinforcements arrived. Neither was Brusilov helped by the tardy responses of Ewart's army group to the north, which should have been pressurising the Germans to prevent their re-deployment.
Gen Alexey Kaledin.
Blazed the trail for Brusilov
into the Volhynian Triangle
h
By late June, Brusilov's greatest successes had been achieved (not without heavy casualties). Kaledin's 8th army and Lechitski's 9th had both advanced more than 50 miles, and taken 200,000 prisoners and large quantities of guns and war material between them.
Thereafter, matters became much more difficult for Brusilov, as German and Austrian reinforcements were pulled all the way from the Western Front and Trentino respectively. Effectively, Kaledin and Lechitski were now fighting separate campaigns, separated by a region where Bothner's Austrian forces were holding on - in one case re-inforced by a German Army Corps that transferred the 1000+ miles from Verdun in only six days. Kaledin and Sakharov made further advances towards their objectives, Kovel and Lemberg, but with heavy losses. Despite the major battle raging on the Somme, the germans were able to mount counter-offensives under another of their outstanding generals, von Linsingen. On one day of such battles, 9th August, the Russians lost 55,000 men. To the south, Lechitski' made valiant efforts to strengthen his grip on Bukovina and to cut off supplies for Bothner's central armies, but by September, Brusilov's offensive had come to an end.

Gen. Alexander von Linsingen
Veteran of the Marne and Ypres 1.
Halted Keldin's charge at the Battle of
Kovel, 24th July 1916
Approximate losses were 1 million for Austria-Hungary, including 400,000 as prisoners; 350,000 for Germany, and 500,000 for Russia. For Austria this was a fatal blow, and she was no longer a serious military player in the war. Thereafter Hindenburg took every significant decision on the Eastern Front. For Russia, although this was their most successful campaign of the war, the high losses in the later stages exacerbated the drop in morale that would culminate in revolution in 1917.
Paradoxically, Brusilov's brilliant successes did most for Britain, France and Italy, weakening appreciably the central powers' efforts in Trentino, Verdun and the Somme. Arguably, had Brusilov been better supported by his colleagues in the central and northern army groups, the offensive might have achieved enough to tip the scales of the Somme conflict in favour of the British.



Tuesday, 3 May 2016

The Italian front and the Trentino offfensive

Bearing little resemblance to today's borders between Italy and her Austrian and Slovenian neighbours, the WW1 front snaked for well over 400 miles (only approx. 200 miles as the crow flies). From Switzerland and its Alps in the west to the plains approaching the Adriatic Sea at Montfalcone just north of Trieste, this serpentine line created by Alpine topography held two enormous salients. The narrower Austro-Hungarian salient contained the Trentino region, subject to multiple Italian attacks in 1915. The broader Italian bulge was formed by the Dolomites and the Carnic Alps - difficult terrain for any strategic moves. This meant that the Italian offensive ambitions (and the majority of their forces) were mainly confined to pushing eastwards across the plains below the Alps. Many great rivers flow across this region from the mountains to the Adriatic, including the Po and Adige south of Venice, and the Isonzo at the eastern extreme. The Isonzo (today the Slovenian river Soca) became one of those infamous WW1 focal points: fought over time and time again with great losses.


  The vulnerability of a typical salient worked both ways for the Trentino. Although on paper it was exposed to Italian attack on all three sides, the Austrians held the high ground and all the mountain passes, making it hazardous for the Italians to advance over hostile steep terrain. In fact, this salient posed a greater threat to Italy, bulging into Italian territory and menacing the rear of the main Italian communications leading eastwards to the Isonzo region. This threat had caused the Italian 1st and 4th armies to make frequent difficult sallies against the Austrian positions during the winter of 1915-16. 
Marmolada in the Dolomites.
Hard to imagine this as a war
front - under 30ft of snow - in 1916

The physical and mental challenges of conducting war in the wintry conditions of the Alps must have been harrowing. Near Cortina in the Dolomites, the Italians tunneled into the mountain for three months, and in April mined a crucial mountain post and blew the Austrians out of it, creating a 150 foot crater in the mountain top. Further west, extraordinary feats by the Alpini – Italian mountain troops – captured small parts of the Trentino salient. In the east, Italy made further pushes towards Gorizia, on the Carso plateau (see map), and the upper gorges of the river Isonzo. Overall, their gains were small but sufficient to threaten important Austrian rail networks. The Austrians needed to counter these threats, and had been making plans to do so.
Upper Isonzo 1916.
Just how did they do it?

The Austrian Commander in Chief, Conrad von Hotzendorf, had been the most belligerent player in the build up to war in 1914. Starved of success, and close to humiliation in Serbia and Galicia, he got on badly with his German ally and opposite number, Falkenhayn. In December 1915 the latter had refused support for Conrad’s proposal to breakthrough from the Trentino, roll up the Italian main forces from the rear and put Italy out of the war. Falkenhayn was too pre-occupied with his own plans to reinforce Verdun from the Eastern Front to offer resources to a man whose abilities he disparaged. By spring however, the Austrians had gathered sufficient strength to try their assault without German support. An advance to the Venetian plain would cut off both main railway lines to the Isonzo.
The Italians were aware of an Austrian build up, but did not expect such a major counter-offensive as was launched upon them on 14th May. A major bombardment, including 800 Howitzers blasted out from the Trentino salient. After eight days of fierce fighting the Austrians were approaching a key objective of Pasubio, north of Vicenza. Desperate defence held them off there, and at Asagio. Further east, heavy fighting in the passes came to a climax on 30th May, when Austria lost 7000 men on that day alone. By 3rd June they had reached the furthest point of their invasion, only 18 miles from Vicenza and the main lines. But they had exhausted their strength, and on that day the Italian Commander in Chief Cadorna announced confidently that the invasion had been halted. He was proved correct.
Luigi Cadorna, Italian C-in-C.
His forces only just managed to
hold off the Austrians

Austria’s major gambit had come close to success, but had failed. Italy was still in the war. Furthermore the cost of packing nearly a million troops and their equipment into the salient had been to weaken significantly their northern forces in Galicia. Although this front had been comparatively quiet through the winter, the Russians were preparing for the next major strategic campaign of 1916 – the Brusilov Offensive.





Monday, 11 April 2016

Postcards from France

I'm just home from a 2 day trip to France which packed in a lot of WW1 viewing. The main reason was to visit Verdun during the centenary and I spent most time there. On the way down I stopped at the Aisne and the Chemin des Dames, and on the way back at Vimy Ridge and Notre Dame de Lorette.
I wanted also to insert a video, showing a tour of the destroyed village of Haumont, obliterated during the opening German assault on Verdun. My main reason for trying it was to capture the birdsong that gives these places such an ethereal quality, but the technology defeated me. Trust me, the birdsong was wondrous.

Battle of the Aisne 1914

 (See Blogs Battle of the Aisne 1 and 2, 27/12/14 and 30/12/14)
Visited two of the BEF's crossing points in the pursuit that followed the Marne victory, Conde and Vailly.  Advances came to a halt against new German defensive positions on the high ground that rises steeply from the north bank of the Aisne to the plain along which runs the famous Chemin des Dames.
The Aisne in full and rapid flow.
I saw a kingfisher, made my morning
Lovely scenery, wonderful views from the top of the escarpment. A beautiful military cemetery is at Vailly sur-Aisne with British and Commonwealth graves numbering nearly 400 and a similar number of French graves.
The French half of the Vailly cemetery with the ridge in the background.
Panoramic view of the plain north of the Aisne, taken from Chemin des Dames



Verdun 1916


This was my fourth visit to Verdun, and still have much to see. I visited all parts of the initial line on 21/2/16., and came upon six of the nine Villages Detruit - 'Mort pour la France' - Haumont, Ornes, Louvemont, Douaumont, Cumieres and Vaux.
The town on the Meuse is both charming and foreboding. The sense of history is pervasive.


Avocourt National Cemetery with Avocourt Wood beyond
In a 12 miles crescent to the north of the town lies the front line, as was on 21st February 1916 when the Germans launched their assault. From Avocourt in the west to Damloups in the east the scars remain amid beautiful rural settings.

Haumont in the Bois
de Haumont
Louvremont memorial on
Cote de Poivre
Vaux devant Damloup
                       


At the eastern end of the salient the ground slopes down steeply from Fort Vaux, to the village itself a short distance for the next Village of Damloup.
In the area shown enormous German losses occurred in their attempts to take Fort Vaux. The single route to the Fort became completely blocked with corpses






Vimy Ridge and Notre Dame de Lorette


The imposing Canadian memorial
The Douai plain from Vimy Ridge.
The slag heaps of Loos are prominent
The Canadians' capture of Vimy Ridge in 1917 followed several unsuccessful attempts by French troops through 1914 and 1915. It's easy to see why it was such important high ground, and the views out over the Douai plain overlook other scenes of carnage including Loos, Aubers Ridge and Lens.

The Necropole de Notre Dame de Lorette
Within view to the north west is another famous hill, now the site of national and international memorials, Notre Dame de Lorette. The struggles for possession of that equally impressive high ground produced many thousands of casualties, the majority of them French. Another very moving visit.





The new NDdeL Memorial


Since I was last there, a new monument has been opened. It reminds me of the Vietnam memorial in Washington. It lists, in alphabetical order, without rank, the names of all troops from both sides killed in the Nord and Pas de Calais of France 1914-18. Astounding  - 580,000 names.
View through the memorial window on NDdeL. The white speck on the horizon is
the Vimy Ridge memorial. The value of high ground.

Wednesday, 6 April 2016

Verdun 6: France holds - "Ils ne passerons"


A poilu's helmet sits on top
of each milestone on the
Voie sacree
This blog post comes from 'on site'. Spending a couple of days at this historic, evocative place, and as I drove up the Voie Sacree from the motorway, it was easy to imagine the scale of the operation needed to keep Verdun supplied. The river Meuse is in flood now, as it probably was 100 years ago at this time. On either bank wholesale slaughter was continuing, as increasingly desperate German efforts sought to make the breakthrough. 
Frustrated through March and April on both banks, the Germans repeatedly changed tactics, testing out French defences with explosive attacks at many different parts of the line. The French resisted determinedly, and tried a few small counter-attacks of their own. The Germans were beginning to lose impetus. 




From the beginning of May to 25th, having tested other parts of the front in the interim, the Germans launched renewed and focused attacks on Mort-Homme. Hill 304, immediately to the west was their greatest success, but they could not reach beyond the lower slopes of Mort-Homme itself. Switching again to the eastern bank, they attacked and carried Hardaumont and Thiaumont farm near the Douaumont and Vaux forts on the 1st June. On 8th June they succeeded in taking Vaux fort and built up to perhaps their biggest effort against the remaining Thiaumont redoubt on 23rd June, which - in typical to and fro combat - they secured one week later. This was the epicentre of a titanic combat through June and early July. The Germans launched 17 Divisions (approx 200,000 men) simultaneously against the line Thiaumont-Fleury-Souville on the right bank. They took Thiaumont, and gained a foothold in Fleury, but not in Souville.

Fleury epitomised the savagery of Verdun. Pre war a sleepy village of around 500 people it became the centre of this phase of the campaign. Already close to destruction from artillery bombardments in March and April, it became the crossroads of numerous mini-campaigns. To visit Fleury today is to find a few foundations and some street signs that indicate the previous layout of the village. Fleury and eight other villages ruined by the battle have not been rebuilt, and are officially designated as "Mort pour la France"

2016
The Germans were almost within sight of the Verdun citadel itself, but following their failure to break the French here, a sense of exhaustion came into their efforts. Nevertheless, they continued with probing attacks until mid-August, including more as far south as les Eparges, but they had reached their furthest advance. They had not taken Mort-Homme, their key objective on the west bank, and had reached only just beyond Douaumont and Vaux on the east, where they were held on a line between Souville and Tavanne forts. From the 1st July the Battle of the Somme dictated the removal of men and materiel to support the outnumbered German lines there.

1916
The battle would continue for a further six months, but not at the same intensity. The French hero of Verdun, Petain, promoted to command the central group of French armies, was removed from the front line in May. His successor, General Nivelle, was a very different kettle of fish and he would oversee near disaster in 1917. He and his deputy, Mangin, reverted to the 'advance at all costs' approach, with high casualty counter-attacks that tested the men's morale to the very limits.




Buchan says of the action to August:

“The result had been a signal French victory. If Verdun represented a less critical moment than the Marne, it was a far more deadly struggle, and it bit deeper into the enemy’s strength”

A Pyrrhic victory - the losses to both sides had been horrific, approaching one million dead, injured or missing. The stench of rotting corpses pervaded the whole area for months. Some poilus had re-designated the Voie sacree as 'le Chemin de l'Abattoir'.
German recriminations began. Marshall von Haesler, the Crown Prince’s Chief of staff and mentor was recalled to Berlin, along with other corps commanders. Falkenhayn’s days were numbered.

We will revisit Verdun before the end of the year.

Wednesday, 23 March 2016

From Western Australia



The Great War was as significant for  'the Dominions' (as they were then called) as it was for Great Britain. Proportionate to their populations, enormous contributions and sacrifices were made by British Empire forces, particularly from Canada, Australia, New Zealand, India and South Africa. I'm spending some time in Perth, Western Australia, where those contributions are marked with feeling and with style. These are a few impressions.....

Centre of Town
Heroes of Gallipoli
and Somme remembered
In the centre of Perth the main road runs through Adelaide Terrace and St. George's Terrace up to the Government Buildings. Paving stones recognise worthy West Australians including heroes of Gallipoli and the Western Front. The ANZAC centre is prominently placed, and the centenary recognised.

Returned and Services League
HQ in Central Perth

King's Park
In beautiful surroundings on the escarpment that overlooks Perth's King's Park has much to remind visitors of WW1.


Contributions to the Boer War (sic) and WW1 are situated along the stunning avenue of lemon scented Eucalyptus trees on Fraser Drive.




Main War Memorial



















Western Front
Particularly moving is a beautiful avenue of gums planted by the nearest and dearest of some of those who died on the Western Front - Fromelles, Pozieres, Amiens.....
















Gallipoli
Several memorials:
A position not unlike that faced, in reverse
by the ANZACs at Gallipoli
Moving post-war words from Ataturk

















Saturday, 12 March 2016

Verdun 5: The general assault - March

The Striking memorial at Mort-Homme
The legend - Ils n'ont pas passe
(They did not pass) 
Having decided to change tactics, the Germans proceeded with customary efficiency to prepare their two pronged pincer attack on the (somewhat flattened) Verdun salient. Their hard won narrow central advance on the right bank of the Meuse was coming under artillery pressure from the French defensive positions on the the left bank. These position were a short term target for the north western pincer. However the main prize, analogous to Douaumont heights on the right bank, was Mort-Homme -Dead Man's Hill. Considering what transpired there, the hill was given its title with eery prescience in the 19th century, named for a traveller who died there, lost in the winter snow. 1916 saw horrors far worse than hypothermia. 

Mort-Homme is the highest part of the ‘Goose’s Crest’ of wooded hills running westwards from Forges and Samogneux. Capture of this would enable almost uninterrupted progress for the four miles southwards to Charny, to the outskirts of Verdun itself. It would also clear the left bank of the French artillery positions that had restricted the initial right bank thrust of the Germans. 
Diagram of the Meuse West Bank
To take Mort-Homme was a major challenge, and would mean taking the whole Goose’s Crest. Only two approaches were possible, either from the north between Forges and Bethincourt, or from further west via Avocourt, and the woods to the west at the base of Mort-Homme.
On the eastern side, they made simultaneous assaults on the villages of Douaumont and Vaux from 4th March. At this stage the main purpose was to divert reinforcements that might be moved to the Mort Homme sector. For a further two days Germans extended the bombardment to the whole north west sector, right round to the Argonne. Then on the 6th, the guns stopped and two German divisions stormed the Forges glen.
As previously, the French fell back in an ordered withdrawal supplemented by some fierce counterattacking. Corbeaux Wood provided a good example of the fighting for Forges and Regneville. It was taken and retaken several times during 6-10th March. Close by to the south west Cumieres Wood and village were the site of three weeks brave resistance by poilus to the massed German infantry attacks, winning great praise from Joffre as “the men who barred the road to Verdun”.
On the 9th March the full pincer force fell on the north east and centred on Vaux. This was a major effort to turn the French line, and they added to it with further attacks from due east through Damloups, Eix and Manheulle. All attacks were repulsed, forcing the Germans to shift their attack back to the north west. Up to 14th March, they made their major effort to take Mort-Homme. The French defensive lines were squeezed to a narrow salient with the village of Bethincourt at its apex. Over three days both sides fought each other almost to a standstill, but the French held on. One more major attack on Vaux was made, and repulsed, before the second phase came to a close, 22 days since the German ‘4 day campaign’ to occupy Verdun had begun. 
The remaining route to take Mort-Homme from the west had not been been seriously attempted, and this now became the German focus. Up to this point both sides had suffered severely, their casualties almost equal, and Falkenhayn was nowhere near his first objective, or his overall plans for the campaign. Nor had there been the expected Allied counter-attack from further west and north on the main front, so that the German reserves were barely occupied.

The new and final phase of these efforts to batter their way through the French defences began from the west, with a three days bombardment up to 20th March. On the afternoon of 20th, the Bavarian infantry, using flamethrowers, advanced from the Avocourt – Malancourt line through the Avocourt wood. They established a redoubt there before pressing on to storm the slopes of Hill 304 next to Mort-Homme. Over 2 days of relentless fighting they reached them, and almost pinched out the salient of the village of Malancourt. There was a lull for 2-3 days while both sides recovered, before the final efforts of the Germans resumed. On the left bank they managed to take Haucourt and drive the French from Bethincourt, but their overall advance was limited to one mile along a front of six miles, and they could not penetrate beyond the lower northern slopes of Hill 304 and Mort-Homme. They eventually took Hill 265 to the west, but could not gain Hill 295 to the east. Pushing again, but from due west, they pounded their way through Malancourt Wood and the village of Avocourt. On the 9th April that reached as far as the north eastern slopes of Mort-Homme and were encroaching on three sides. Petain’s rallying cry came the following morning:
“April 9th was a glorious day for our armies, the furious attacks of the soldiers of the Crown Prince broke down everywhere. The infantry, artillery, sappers and aviators of the 2nd Army vied with one another in valour. Honour to all. No doubt the Germans will attack again. Let all work and watch, that yesterday’s success be continued. Courage! We shall beat them!”
and indeed the last German efforts here ran out of steam on that day.

The severely battered Fort Vaux in
March 1916

On the east bank, similar desperate assaults had continued towards Vaux. They took the western side of the village, and were able to advance some way towards the plateau of Douaumont, but it was a narrow route that soon became congested with weaponry and increasing numbers of dead and dying, and their advances ground to a halt. Their losses were very high, and spelt the end of the third phase of the broad assault. both pincers had been blunted.